This deodorant really works, the scent is lovely. Unfortunately I had to stop using it because I had an allergic rhinitis reaction to the scent, I switched to unscented now.
While I used this one I found it very long lasting, I obly applied it once a day and still felt fresh the following morning. I didn't have a problem using it in the tube, my previous deodorant comes in a tube only, but this one is a little soft so it's best to only push it up just enough to apply. One day when it clearly only had a tiny bit left, I took the lid off and the end of the deodorant was sucked into the lid and couldn't be extracted, so I just had to use it from there. For that reason I recommend that you buy the refillable version.

Nice smell, but awful packaging. If you want to put the lid back on you have to sort of mash it into the top of the push up stick. It realy doesn't work. So, fine, if you never need to put the lid back on.